Custom Cakes

The Carl's Cakes teams can create a one-of-a-kind cake for your event, no matter the style or the budget. Creative designs, delicious cake flavors, and delightful buttercreams make Carl’s Cakes the most recommended cakes in the Madison area.

 Colleen the Koala

 Buttercream Ruffles

 Samuel L. Dogson

 Confetti Celebration


 Birthday Fun

 Sprinkle Explosion

 Welcome Baby

 Candy Border

 Religious Celebration

 Fun Rosettes

 Colorful Scrollwork

 Party Streamers

 Daniel the Dinosaur

 Fun with Flowers

Inquiry Form


When would you like to pick up your cake?
(Please specify date and time.)

Cake Flavor
Filling Flavor
Number of people you are serving
Cake Budget
Tell us what you have in mind (theme, colors, etc).
If you have and image of the design you have in mind, please upload it here. (You may select more than one image in the pop up window.)

Someone from the bakery will contact you via email to answer any questions you have, and finalize details of your pending order.
This is not an order form and does not guarantee completion of your cake. **Please add to your safe senders list and/or check your spam folder.